As new trial date nears, here’s what’s new about the Scott Peterson case

Scott Peterson Trial

REDWOOD CITY, Calif. (KRON) — Sources close to Scott Peterson revealed to KRON4 details about new evidence that his defense team plans to use for his new trial this year.

Peterson has always maintained his innocence, and he plans to prove it.

“The thing to understand is, there is a whole new case out there to defend Scott Peterson. There is much more powerful testimony out there,” said Dean Johnson, a former San Mateo County prosecutor who closely follows the Peterson case.

A hearing was held on January 21 in San Mateo County Superior Court, where Peterson appear via a livestream from San Quentin Prison. March 12 was announced as a possible date when the judge will decide if Peterson will get a whole new trial for the guilt phase.

Scott Peterson
Scott Peterson ( Getty Images )

Peterson’s pregnant wife, Laci, went missing on Christmas Eve in 2002 and her body was later found in the San Francisco Bay. The body of Peterson’s unborn baby, Connor, was also found nearby.

Peterson said he had gone fishing at the Berkeley Marina when she vanished. His attorneys are going to try to prove that Laci and Connor died sometime after he left their Modesto home on Christmas Eve to go fishing.

One witness who is expected to deliver new testimony will be Russell Graybill. Graybill is a mailman who delivered mail to the Peterson’s house regularly.

The Peterson’s dog, Mckenzi, always barked at the mailman. But the day Laci vanished, Mckenzi did not bark.

Laci Peterson and Scott Peterson
Laci Peterson and Scott Peterson

According to the writ of habeas corpus, the dog never barked because it was out walking with Laci. The mailman went to the house between 10:35 a.m. and 10:50 a.m., which is a time period after Scott Peterson allegedly left that morning to go fishing.

The mailman was interviewed by police three days after Laci went missing. But he was never allowed to testify during the murder trial.

A third set of new witnesses are neighbors who say they saw a woman and dog matching Laci and Mckenzi’s descriptions out walking after Peterson left their Modesto neighborhood. Laci was eight months pregnant at the time.

Frank Aguilar is one person who claims to have seen Laci out walking the dog sometime between 9:30 and 11:00. Another alleged eye-witness of Laci walking the dog that morning is Diane Campos.

“None of these witnesses/declarants had any reason to lie for Scott Peterson,” Peterson’s habeas corpus petition states. “If it was Laci who took Mckenzi for a walk after 10:18 and left the gate open, no juror could vote to convict since at that point Scott was well on his way to the warehouse and the marina.”

“There are eyewitnesses out there who can actually testify the facts that would make Scott Peterson’s guilt impossible to believe,” Johnson said.

Sources close with Peterson told KRON4 that another strong piece of new evidence centers around the Medina home burglary.

On Dec. 24, 2002, the Peterson’s neighbor’s house was burglarized. One neighbor, Diane Jackson, told police that she saw burglars removing a safe from the house across the street from the Peterson’s home on Covena Avenue. The Medina family lived in the home at the time, and they were out of town on vacation.

According to a private investigator hired by Peterson’s family, a group of men who allegedly conducted the burglary are now considered prime suspects of murdering Laci.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker

Trending Stories

Latest News

More News